Immune check-point inhibitors (ICPIs) are monoclonal antibodies against inhibitory receptors on T-cells resulting in anti-cancer activity. In kidney transplant recipients, ICPI use has been associated with acute allograft rejection. In failed allografts, however, the effects of ICPIs are unknown. We present a case of a 66-year old man with a history of diabetes, renal cell cancer, left native nephrectomy and end-stage kidney disease. He received a deceased donor kidney transplant which failed after 6 years due to biopsy proven recurrent diabetic nephrosclerosis. He was started on hemodialysis and his immunosuppression was gradually weaned off. A year later, he was diagnosed with renal cell cancer in his right native kidney requiring nephrectomy. He later developed metastasis and was started on combination ICPIs. He developed hematuria, allograft pain, and malaise consistent with graft intolerance syndrome 28 days after starting ICPIs. Urine culture and cystoscopy were normal. A computed tomography scan of his abdomen revealed an enlarged allograft with patchy enhancement. After a multidisciplinary discussion, he underwent transplant nephrectomy. Histopathology showed chronic active T-cell mediated rejection. As ICPI use becomes prevalent, practitioners need to be aware of its potential complications among kidney transplant recipients both with functioning and failed allografts.This article is protected by copyright. All rights reserved.