by Physician’s Weekly blogger, Skeptical Scalpel
At the annual meeting of the American Economic Association, Nobel Prize winner Angus Deaton said to the Washington Post, “Physicians are a giant rent-seeking conspiracy that’s taking money away from the rest of us, and yet everybody loves physicians you can’t touch them.”
According to David R. Henderson, a research fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution and an associate professor of economics, rent-seeking is “the payment to a factor of production in excess of what is required to keep that factor in its present use.” For example, if you had a Super Bowl ticket with a face value of $2000 and you scalped it for $3000, the $1000 profit would be considered “rent.” When you ask your boss for a raise, you are rent-seeking. Henderson sees nothing wrong with rent-seeking.
To build his case, Deaton says “We have half as many physicians per head as most European countries, yet they [meaning US doctors] get paid two times as much, on average.” Doesn’t Deaton’s statement imply American physicians might be doing twice as much work? If we had the same number of physicians per capita and were paid like European doctors, wouldn’t the costs be about the same?
A 2018 study published in JAMA looked at healthcare spending in the US and other high-income countries and had this to say about physician incomes: “Although remuneration varies widely across systems, the optimal level of compensation remains unclear. Salaries in the United States may be high, but recent debates on remuneration of medical staff in the United Kingdom and France…suggest that salaries in other countries may be too low.” Deaton may not be factoring in the average debt for med school graduates, which is now about $200,000 with interest accruing during their low paying residency training years.
Physician reimbursement is set by the market, not the doctor. About half of practicing physicians are in private practice. They may bill whatever they want, but the amount they receive is whatever private insurance, Medicare, or Medicaid decide is appropriate. Salaried doctors, the other half, are paid by their hospitals or groups, organizations incentivized to keep salaries as low as possible. The way to decrease what doctors make is to make more doctors, which is happening right now.
Deaton’s insults came to light at the same time as an Annals of Internal Medicine paper finding that compared to Canada, the US pays twice as much for administration of its healthcare system. Canada pays 17% of its healthcare expenditures for administrative costs, while we pay 34%. Interacting with payers cost US doctors an average of $169,000 yearly or 21% of gross receipts. The authors of the study said “Discussions of health reform in the United States should consider whether $812 billion devoted annually to health administration is money well spent.”
While Canadian doctors pay a little under $37,000 per year.
The economists aren’t happy with “surprise billing” that occurs when a doctor who is “out of network” cares for a patient in a hospital that is “in network.” Although they are economists, they apparently don’t understand that some doctors are out of network because certain insurance companies—knowing they have leverage—low-ball doctors during contract negotiations or even simply say “take what we offer or leave it.” Those choosing to “leave it” are out of network.
I get that some doctors charge too much, but we are not the reason the US healthcare system is so expensive, nor are we rent-seeking.
I think the economists are just jealous. After all, have you ever heard anyone say they loved an economist?
Skeptical Scalpel is a retired surgeon and was a surgical department chair and residency program director for many years. He is board-certified in general surgery and a surgical sub-specialty and has re-certified in both several times.For the last 9 years, he has been blogging at SkepticalScalpel.blogspot.com and tweeting as @SkepticScalpel. His blog has had more than 3,700,000 page views, and he has over 21,000 followers on Twitter.
SkepticalScalpel
That’s disgusting. What if we start to lift people up instead of bringing them down? Maybe punish the ones that are certainly guilty instead of insulting people who work hard and try to make people’s lives better? And maybe pay others more instead of saying physicians don’t deserve the money they’re getting paid? It’s definitely not their fault that the U.S. Healthcare system as a whole needs a ton of work and improvement and instead of insulting them and talk nonsense this “Noble Prize winner” should’ve proposed a good solution.
As a board-certified cardiologist at a major academic medical center, I entirely agree with Dr. Deaton that physicians are largely responsible for the fact that United States (U. S.) healthcare costs average twice those of other developed nations, the U. S. has the poorest longevity of all of them, and one of the most sedentary obese populations in the world. The American Medical Association-controlled Relative Value Unit (RVU) Update Committee, which largely determines Medicare reimbursement rates (taxpayer funded dollars paid to physicians) is heavily stacked with subspecialists who perform markedly over-valued procedures (relative to their effect on clinical outcome and their cost in other developed nations) such as coronary artery interventions, cardiac and magnetic resonance imaging, CT scans, back surgery, arthroscopic knee surgery, Cesarean sections, etc. etc. No wonder these procedures are overused, their prices are excessive, and morale is poor among generalist physicians. The U. S. medical profession also should be held accountable for the opioid epidemic because it very easily could (and should) have said no to the pharmaceutical industry. Finally, U. S. medical schools have done an absolutely abysmal job of teaching physicians about exercise and nutrition. Hence, they are very ill-equipped to counsel patients on the 2 most effective healthcare interventions in medicine.
Dear Wade Martin, MD,
Thank you ofr your well thoughtout response and your willingness to offer a countering opinion.
When I try to understand something unknown and difficult I often extrapolate and imagine the situation
at a point of exaggeration. it can often bring out contracdiction and loopholes.healthcare in the US has
gotten to the hyper end of the spectrum and thd strain is showing. Thank you for helping make more visible
the problem and helping those in denial remove their blinders as to what is driving the cost.
I’m 72 and since I was a boy I’ve been hearing of the threat posed by “socialized medicine” from overhearing my father, my uncle and my grandfather – pharmacists all – discussing the supposed impact on their livelihood as owners of a small wholesale drug supply warehouse in North Dakota.
please give me your honest opinion of Medicare for All. i have supported Bernie Sanders for President since he ran years ago and now he seems to have a real shot at winning the Democratic Party’s nomination. I feel we are at a crossroad and our democracy hangs in the balance. nonetheless I hear it drummed out everyday by the media talking heads that people will be worried that losing their current heathcare plan will be something they’ll regret.
Again, do you think Medicare for All will cause him to lose the election in November. Brian in Western Massachusetts
You’re working for free, right? Leading by example? There’s no “opioid epidemic” that can’t be laid at the feet of people with pre-existing psychological and substance abuse problems, which is why millions of Americans have procedures and can’t wait to get off the pain meds they’re given. And you don’t have to go to medical school to know the value of exercise and nutrition. It’s a topic covered in grade school health classes. This is the end product of 13 years of post-graduate schooling? US medicine is expensive because doctors don’t slap people around enough for eating fried Twinkies?
Contracts are not just about fees. I declined a contract because it required me to allow my personal cell phone to be pre-programed into their drug addicts free Obama phones. Take it or leave it.
All true, but I fear the public has drawn its conclusions. It will take decades to undo the damage, and in the meantime non-physician providers will provide more health care at the expense of patient health and lives (already happening and it’s terrifying).
Here’s another great response by Dr. Karen Sibert, well worth a read.
http://apennedpoint.com/keep-up-the-insults-and-good-luck-finding-a-physician-in-10-years/
BTW, all that non-physician care ends up costing more as NPs and PAs order more unnecessary tests. Administrators say cha-ching! It’s a big mess and my best hope is to do everything I can to stay healthy via lifestyle measures (and hope I don’t suffer a catastrophic injury or develop a chronic condition).
Thanks. I agree Dr. Sibert’s post is worth reading.
Thanks for great blog post. The cottage industry around medicine which physicians have no control over driven by bean counters and alike is killing the goose that lays the golden egg. Physicians are being killed (figuratively since we are way smarter and know how to find and use short-cuts where appropriate) by admin burden and enriching everyone other than physicians taking care of patients.
I can think of no profession in the world that caused more harm than economists. I suppose that the irony scapes Professor Deaton.
If rent-seeking means wanting to be paid more than 12% more than I paid my PCP 30 years ago, then I am rent-seeking. Unfortunately as a PCP in a small town, rent-seeking to me is more seeking for money to pay the rent.
Maybe rent seeking behavior by venture capitalists, hedge fund managers, and many CEOs would be a better target for his ire.
Based on his logic I could argue anyone with a government mandated license to do their job is causing a limit to supply and therefore rent seeking. But these licenses are in place because the government (and by extension the overall population) has decided certain professions should have prerequisite training and oversight to assure safety. Do we let anyone who wants to fly a plane get into a Delta 747? No you have to complete the appropriate training and get a commercial pilot license. Same with lawyers and RNs and many other professions.
Angus Deaton is right. Boo hoo if our delicate sensibilities are offended.
Judging from the responses to this on Twitter, your views are among the few in the minority.