Donor proteinuria (DP) is a common but rarely evaluated aspect of today’s kidney transplant allocation process. While proteinuria after kidney transplantation is a risk factor for impaired graft function and survival, the long-term effects of DP in kidney transplantation have not yet been evaluated. Therefore, this study aims to investigate the impact of DP on the long-term outcome after kidney transplantation. A total of 587 patients were found to be eligible and were stratified into two groups: (1) those receiving a graft from a donor without proteinuria (DP-) and (2) those receiving a graft from a donor with proteinuria (DP+). At 36 months, there was no difference in the primary composite endpoint including graft loss and patient survival (log-rank test, = 0.377). However, the analysis of DP+ subgroups showed a significant decrease in overall patient survival in the group with high DP ( = 0.017). DP did not adversely affect patient or graft survival over 36 months. Nevertheless, this work revealed a trend towards decreased overall survival of patients with severe proteinuria in the subgroup analysis. Therefore, the underlying results suggest caution in allocating kidneys from donors with high levels of proteinuria.Copyright © 2023 Pollmann, Vogel, Pongs, Katou, Morgül, Houben, Görlich, Kneifel, Reuter, Pollmann, Pascher and Becker.